Mason Gaffney, October 18, 1923-July 16, 2020

My old friend and mentor, Mason Gaffney, died last week at his home in Redlands, California. I thank David Cay Johnston for a warm and insightful obituary in the New York Times. I also thank Wyn Achenbaum and Nic Tideman and the Schalkenbach Foundation for an extraordinary tribute with excerpts from his writing. Especially check out Mason’s timely article, The Red and the Blue, on why high median income cities like New York and San Francisco vote blue, while low income regions vote red: Land values are disproportionately high in prosperous big cities, making homeownership “unaffordable” for middle class residents. So they rent—and vote blue. Suburban and small-town homeowners vote red.

I first met Mase in 1970. My husband and I were working on Ralph Nader’s “Power and Land in California” project. In researching that boondoggle visible from the moon, the California State Water Project, I had encountered a scholarly article on irrigation canals, canals that crisscrossed each other delivering water to those who least needed it while bypassing those who needed it most. The article was not only devastating, but funny, so funny I laughed out loud. I had to meet the author!

Come Christmas, we looked up Mase in Washington DC, where he was a scholar at Resources for the Future. He invited us to dinner at his apartment. After frying us up hamburgers with soy sauce, he whipped out his guitar and sang a few numbers from Tom Lehrer–I remember one about “sliding down the razor blade of life.” And Gilbert and Sullivan songs, to his own words. We talked late. I don’t remember about what, but I was enthralled. He sent us off with a packet of reprints and an enjoinder I didn’t then get: “Tax capital and you drive it away; tax land and you drive it into use.”

Soon enough, I dropped out of grad school in ancient Near Eastern languages and followed his trail to the Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics at Berkeley. Here, with the help of the massive reading lists he sent me, I eventually learned to apply real economics to big questions, starting with what keeps societies unequal and wages low.

Mase loved a good party. Once, we gave a party for him at our apartment on Telegraph Hill in San Francisco. He and wife Tish and baby Laura were traveling from British Columbia to UC Riverside. A bagpiper appeared on the street outside. Really loud. Tish worried he’d wake the baby. But Mase invited the man in and sang numbers with him while the guests clapped and cheered.

Mase and I stayed in touch by letters and email over the years. I wish so much I had managed a last visit before Covid struck. I’ll always miss him. And I’ll always be grateful for everything he taught me, for his courage and honesty in confronting bastardized economics and history, and for his generosity, clarity and humor in this benighted world.

5 comments to Mason Gaffney, October 18, 1923-July 16, 2020

  • Richard Milner

    Lovely tribute, Polly. Clear, intellectual, uncluttered, yet warm, emotional and from the heart. I will check out the various tributes and his article that you have referenced. Through your introduction some years ago, I had a brief but interesting correspondence with Gaffney about his favorite econ writer — Henry George. Well done!!

  • Thanks, Polly, for this wonderful remembrance of a wonderful person.

  • Catherine Orloff

    Thanks for this great tribute, Polly. I remember when I worked with Bob Tideman at the HGSSS in SF, you and Mase were frequent and welcome visitors. You two were “Academe hails Georgism!” Bob would actually stop his huge printing press and sit with you one and all to have a friendly conversation that would usually veer to economics and HG one way or another, and to the health of the HGSSS in California, including Harry Pollard’s fiefdom to the South! Great old days, so many P&P classes were advertised and run throughout CA; so many volunteer “discussion leaders” were trained, etc. I have run a few P&P classes at our First Unitarian Church here in Providence….I should resume them now that my 2 kids are married and settled….All best, Cathy Covell Orloff

  • Paul Fagan

    He was a brilliant economist, lively and interesting. I knew him personally at UC, Riverside.

  • This is a beautiful tribute, Polly. Thank you for posting it.